top of page

Time to Rethink What It Means to Be School-Ready?

Writer: Joanne Baldwin
Joanne Baldwin
22 hours ago
5 min read

Time to Rethink What It Means to Be School-Ready? One in four children starting Reception is not toilet-trained, while many more are struggling with independence.

One in four children starting Reception isn't toilet-trained, while many more struggle with independence, communication, emotional regulation, and the expectation to sit still and learn. But before we blame parents, children, or schools, perhaps we need to ask a bigger question: have our expectations of young children moved beyond what is developmentally realistic?


Something is troubling about the growing conversation around school readiness.

Increasingly, we hear about children starting school without being toilet-trained, struggling to follow instructions, finding it difficult to sit still, or lacking the independence that teachers understandably hope to see when a new Reception class walks through the door.


The statistics make uncomfortable reading. According to the 2025 School Readiness Survey by early years charity Kindred Squared, published in January 2026, 26% of children starting Reception were reported by teachers to be not toilet-trained. More than one in three children (37%) were considered not school-ready overall.

The same research found that 44% of children were reported to struggle with sitting still, while 37% struggled to listen and respond to simple instructions.

These figures raise important questions, not least about the pressure on teachers, families, and children themselves.


But I wonder whether we are asking the right question.

Instead of simply asking why so many children are not ready for school, should we also ask whether school expects children to be ready for things that are not necessarily appropriate for their age and stage of development?


The changing meaning of school readiness

School readiness is not a new concept. Historically, children have always been expected to acquire certain skills before entering formal education.


In England, the Education Act 1870 established compulsory education, with age 5 becoming the minimum age for compulsory school attendance. This reflected a very different society, with different family structures, expectations of childhood and approaches to education.

Over the generations, the experience of starting school has changed considerably.

Many older generations remember starting school at five, spending much of their time playing, exploring, singing, listening to stories and gradually learning classroom routines. There was an understanding, even if not always explicitly expressed, that children arrived with different abilities and that school was somewhere they developed many of the skills they needed.


Today, the transition into Reception can feel rather different.

There is greater emphasis on measurable progress, early literacy and numeracy, assessment and developmental milestones. Although the Early Years Foundation Stage (EYFS) recognises the importance of play and individual development, there can be a perceived tension between the principles of early childhood education and the practical expectations placed on children entering school. We have to be careful not to confuse being ready to learn with being ready to behave like a much older child.


A four-year-old is still very much a young child. They are developing physically, socially, emotionally and cognitively, and these areas do not all develop at the same pace.

Perhaps our definition of school readiness needs to reflect that.


The expectation to sit still: are we forgetting what four-year-olds are like?

One of the most interesting findings in the latest research is how many children struggle to sit still.

But let's pause for a moment.

Have we ever really expected a four-year-old to sit still for extended periods? Should we?

Young children learn through movement. They explore their environment by touching, climbing, running, jumping, experimenting and asking questions. Their curiosity is often expressed physically, and their ability to manage impulses, concentrate and regulate their emotions is still developing.


In fact, the Department for Education's own guidance on self-regulation acknowledges that fidgeting and needing support are developmentally appropriate at this age. It specifically warns that many children, particularly those who are younger within the Reception year, may struggle to sit still.


This is an important distinction.

There is a difference between a child who cannot engage with learning and a child who learns best when they are moving.

There is also a difference between teaching children to listen, take turns and participate in group activities and expecting them to remain quiet and physically still for long periods.

We should encourage concentration, not demand adult-like behaviour from children whose brains and bodies are still developing.


A classroom that allows movement, practical exploration, outdoor learning and short, engaging activities may be far more effective for many young children than one which relies heavily on sitting at tables and listening.

The question should not simply be how we get children to sit still, but how we create environments in which they can learn successfully and play for longer, delaying formal teaching.


Potty training: a life skill, not a measure of parenting

The statistic that one in four children starts school without being toilet-trained has understandably attracted considerable attention.


Teachers are often expected to manage changing clothes, accidents, and individual toileting needs, taking time away from teaching a whole class. It is also important for children's confidence, independence, and comfort. However, we need to approach this subject with compassion rather than criticism.


Toilet training is a developmental process involving physical awareness, communication, coordination, emotional readiness and the ability to recognise and respond to bodily signals.


The NHS now advises that almost all children can be toilet-trained between 18 months and two-and-a-half years, and the Department for Education's guidance encourages families and early years settings to support the process between 18 and 30 months.

Yet knowing when to start and successfully achieving independence are not necessarily the same thing.


Children develop at different rates. Some have additional needs, physical difficulties, sensory sensitivities or medical conditions which make toilet training more complicated. Others experience constipation, anxiety or setbacks. We also need to consider changing family circumstances.


Parental Support

Parents today may have less informal support from extended families, different working patterns and less access to the consistent professional guidance that previous generations sometimes received. ERIC, the children's bowel and bladder charity, has highlighted concerns about reduced health visitor capacity and fewer opportunities for parents to access practical toilet-training advice.

This is not about suggesting that parents have no responsibility. Helping children develop independence is an important part of parenting and early years education.

But responsibility needs support.

If we expect children to arrive at school with particular skills, we must ensure families have access to clear information, practical guidance, and help when things don't go to plan.

Shaming parents will not solve the problem. Supporting them might.


Research and references

The following sources underpin the article and would be useful to include as further reading:

1. Kindred Squared (2025 School Readiness Survey, published January 2026) – The latest survey of more than 1,000 primary school staff and 1,000 parents. Reports 26% of Reception children not toilet-trained and 37% considered not school-ready. Read the survey findings.

2. Department for Education – Self-regulation in the Early Years – Particularly relevant to the discussion about sitting still, fidgeting and developmental expectations. Read the guidance.

3. NHS – Potty training your child – Current advice on toilet training and developmental support. Read NHS guidance.

4. ERIC – The Children's Bowel & Bladder Charity – Explores the importance of supporting parents rather than blaming them for toilet-training difficulties. Read ERIC's perspective.

5. UK Parliament – The history of education – Historical background to the 1870 and 1880 Education Acts. Read the historical record.

6. Education Endowment Foundation – Earlier Starting Age – Examines evidence around the educational benefits and considerations of starting early education earlier. Explore the research.

7. Department for Education – Early Years Foundation Stage – Explains the importance of play-based learning and the seven areas of early development. Read the EYFS overview.

An important research qualification: the Kindred Squared figures are estimates reported by surveyed school staff, not a census of every child starting Reception. They provide a valuable indication of pressures in schools, but should be presented as survey findings rather than definitive national statistics.

Comments


bottom of page